![]()
It was always this time of year when my Hungarian grandma would get out her big pots and fill them up with her stuffed peppers. The fragrance of sweet peppers and paprika would fill the Indiana farm kitchen. At meal time, thick slices of her homemade bread would be used to soak up extra gravy on the plate. I remember times when I would make a meal of just bread and the paprika-spiked gravy. My grandma would always shape some of the meat mixture into balls, tucking them into the pot with the stuffed peppers. My brother and I would get the flavor of the peppers in the meatballs that had simmered in the gravy, but we wouldn’t have to eat a pepper.
My mom would recreate the stuffed peppers at our home in Minnesota, hundreds of miles away from my grandma’s Indiana farm. They were always delicious, but never quite the same as those my grandma made with peppers picked from her garden.
I don’t have a garden, but I do have a farmers’ market I can visit to find beautiful fresh sweet bell peppers. I cook up a big pot of Hungarian-Style Stuffed Peppers and then freeze them in the tomato juice they were simmered in. On one of the first cool fall days, I pull a container of the peppers out of the freezer and heat them up. In another pot, I cook up lots of potatoes for mashing. There’s nothing like a big mound of mashed potatoes with a stuffed pepper and lots of the thickened gravy.
This recipe makes lots of stuffed peppers. Exactly how many depends on the size of the peppers you will use. If you have more meat mixture left after you’ve stuffed all your peppers, just form the remaining meat into balls. Roll them in flour before adding them to the pot.
After the stuffed peppers have cooked, I like to store them in the refrigerator for a day before portioning them into containers to freeze. This allows the flavors to develop. I don’t thicken the gravy until I reheat them at serving time.
The gravy is thickened with a roux flavored with lots of onions and paprika.
My grandma and my mom never measured anything when they cooked, so I just learned how things were supposed to look or feel. So, this recipe is one you’ll need to prepare Hungarian style: make, taste, adjust, taste, adjust. Be sure to use the freshest paprika you can get. If you’ve had a bottle sitting on your shelf for a year, get a new one. I like the Hungarian paprika from Penzey’s. Next month I’ll be going to Hungary, so I’ll be getting paprika right from the source.
And let me tell you, it’s hard to get a photo of Hungarian-Style Stuffed Peppers that looks beautiful. It’s a comfort meal — a big mound of mashed potatoes, green peppers that have cooked so long they fall apart in the gravy, and ground meat with rice, both cooked to perfect tenderness. It may not look beautiful, but it tastes absolutely delicious.
Hungarian-Style Stuffed Peppers
2 1/2 to 3 pounds ground beef
1 pound ground pork
2 eggs
2 large onions
1 cup uncooked long-grain rice
1 teaspoon salt
2 teaspoons Hungarian paprika
Green bell peppers
All-purpose flour
9 cups tomato juice
2 1/2 cups water
For thickening gravy:
Shortening
Chopped onions
Paprika
Flour
Put ground meats, eggs, onions, rice, salt and paprika in large bowl. Use your hands to mix the ingredients together. Wash peppers. Cut in half lengthwise. Clean out seeds and membranes.
Stuff the meat mixture into pepper halves, packing it in tightly and mounding the mixture slightly. Dip all exposed meat in flour. Place stuffed peppers in pot, meat side facing up. Pour tomato juice into pot. Add enough water so that peppers are covered. Cover pot and bring to a boil. Simmer until rice is tender and meat is cooked, at least an hour.
To thicken gravy, melt quite a bit of shortening in a small pan. Add chopped onion and cook until tender. Add paprika until the mixture is nice and red. Add flour gradually, stirring after each addition. Don’t let the mixture get too thick. Remove pepper pot from heat and stir in the thickening mixture. When the gravy is blended, put the pot back on the heat. Bring it back to a low boil, stirring occasionally, until the gravy is thickened.
